A £20,000 quote for an extension can look far better than one for £25,000. But if the lower figure leaves out steelwork, drainage, waste removal or VAT, it may not be cheaper at all. Learning how to compare builder quotations properly is less about finding the lowest number and more about knowing exactly what each number buys you.
If you are still puzzled about why your quotes are so far apart, start with our guide Why are my builder quotes so different?. This article picks up where that one stops: once the quotes are on the table, here is how to compare them item by item and decide which one to accept.
Make sure every builder priced the same pack
You can only compare quotes fairly when every builder has priced the same job. If one contractor worked from a sketch, another from planning drawings and a third from a full building regulations package with structural details, their figures will differ for reasons that have nothing to do with value.
Before comparing anything, check what each builder was given. For most extensions and loft conversions the pack should include measured drawings, proposed plans and elevations, a written scope of works and any structural engineering information. If planning permission has been granted, include the decision notice and approved drawings.
If the packs were different, send the missing information to everyone and ask for revised prices. It is quicker than trying to adjust the figures yourself.
Build a simple comparison sheet
Put the quotes side by side in a spreadsheet. List the work sections down the left in the order they happen on site, with one column per builder. Then work through each quote and fill in the price for every section, or write "excluded" or "not shown".
A typical list for an extension:
- Preliminaries: site set-up, welfare, skips, scaffolding, protection, supervision
- Demolition and strip-out
- Excavation, foundations and groundworks
- Drainage
- Structure: brickwork and blockwork, steelwork, roof structure
- Roof coverings, windows and external doors
- Insulation, plastering and internal partitions
- Electrics, plumbing and heating
- Kitchen, bathroom and joinery
- Floor finishes and decoration
- External works and making good
- Final clean and waste removal
For a loft conversion, add structural steel, floor strengthening, stair alterations, fire doors and roof windows as separate lines. These are where loft quotes most often differ.
Any blank cell is a question to send back. The total at the bottom only means something once every row has an answer.
Read the preliminaries first
Preliminaries are the costs of running the site rather than building anything: scaffolding, skips, welfare facilities, temporary protection, site management and insurance. Some builders list them, some spread them across their rates, and some leave them out and add them once work starts.
If one quote shows £6,000 of preliminaries and another shows none, the second has not made them disappear. Ask where they are.
Compare allowances, not just totals
Two kinds of estimate appear in most residential quotes:
- Provisional sums cover work that cannot be priced exactly yet, such as drainage where the existing route is unknown, or groundworks before the soil has been seen.
- Prime cost allowances are budgets for items you will choose later, such as sanitaryware, tiles, kitchen units or light fittings.
Both are normal. The risk is allowances that are unrealistically low, because the difference comes back to you as an extra. A £1,500 bathroom allowance may cover a basic cloakroom but not a family bathroom with a shower, vanity unit and tiling.
Copy every allowance into its own row on your sheet, so you can see them side by side. Then ask each builder three things: what the allowance covers, whether it includes fitting, delivery and VAT, and how any overspend will be priced. Where you already know what you want, give every builder the same product list or budget level so the allowances match.
Check the exclusions list
The exclusions are often the most useful part of a quote. Common ones include building control fees, structural engineer inspections, party wall surveyor fees, utility connections, specialist reports and making good the garden.
An exclusion is not a problem in itself, provided you know about it and have allowed for it in your overall budget. Put each excluded item on your sheet with an estimated cost, so the totals you compare include everything you will actually pay.
Put every quote on the same VAT basis
Some builders quote including VAT, some excluding it, and some are not VAT registered. A £30,000 quote excluding VAT becomes £36,000 once 20% is added.
Ask every builder to state clearly whether VAT is included, excluded or not applicable, and compare the amounts you expect to pay in total. Do not assume a reduced rate applies to your project. Some work does qualify, but get proper advice rather than relying on it to make a quote look competitive.
Compare programme and site management
Price is not the only difference worth comparing. Add rows to your sheet for:
- proposed start date and programme length
- who manages the site day to day, and how often they attend
- how many people will normally be on site
- working hours, deliveries, parking and access
- how you will receive progress updates
A very low quote matters less if the builder cannot start for nine months. A very short programme matters less if it depends on assumptions that will not survive the first week on site. If you are living in the house during the work, clear communication and an organised site can be worth more than a small saving.
Compare payment stages and variations
Payments should follow visible progress rather than calendar dates. A typical schedule might cover foundations, structural shell, roof and weathertight, first fix, plastering, second fix and practical completion. A deposit can be reasonable for early mobilisation or bespoke materials, but its purpose and amount should be stated. Avoid paying large sums ahead of completed work.
Then compare how each builder will handle changes. The safest arrangement is a written price and programme impact for any extra work before it starts, except in a genuine emergency. A low price combined with vague wording on variations is a warning sign: the quote wins the job, then the final cost is decided through a series of extras.
Check the builder behind each quote
A clear quote is a good sign, but it does not replace basic checks. Confirm public liability insurance, and employers' liability where the builder employs staff. Ask for recent examples of similar work, and if possible speak to previous clients about whether the job finished close to the agreed price and how changes were handled. Confirm that electrical and gas work will be done and certified by competent, registered installers.
Send the same questions to everyone
When your sheet is complete, you will have a list of gaps, low allowances and unclear exclusions for each builder. Send each builder the questions that apply to their quote, with the same deadline, and ask for a revised figure where something has been missed.
The aim is not to make every quote reach the same total. Builders have different overheads and ways of working. It is to make sure you understand where the differences come from.
Before you accept a quote, you should be able to answer four questions:
- What is included?
- What is excluded, and what will it cost me separately?
- What could change the price?
- How will changes be agreed?
If any answer is unclear, the quote is not ready to accept. Once you have chosen, make sure the scope, drawings, payment schedule, programme and variation procedure are written into the contract, not left in the quote alone.
Getting help with the comparison
Comparing quotes line by line takes time, and it is easier when the tender pack was clear in the first place. Capital Architecture prepares the drawings, specifications and scopes of works that let builders price the same job, and our Build Quote Appraisal service reviews quotes you have already received and tells you what is missing before you sign.
The right quote is rarely the cheapest piece of paper. It is the one that matches your approved design, sets realistic expectations and leaves you confident about what happens when work begins.
Check my builder's quote
Check my builder's quote →